|本期目录/Table of Contents|

 ZHANG Jiajia,WU Shenghe,Research progress on the depositional architecture of submarine-fan lobes[J].China Offshore Oil and Gas,2019,31(05):88-106.[doi:10.11935/j.issn.1673-1506.2019.05.010]





Research progress on the depositional architecture of submarine-fan lobes
张佳佳1 2 吴胜和1 2
(1. 中国石油大学(北京)地球科学学院 北京 102249; 2. 中国石油大学(北京)油气资源与探测国家重点实验室 北京 102249)
ZHANG Jiajia1 2 WU Shenghe1 2
(1. College of Geosciences,China University of Petroleum, Beijing 102249, China; 2. State Key Laboratory of Petroleum Resources and Prospecting, China University of Petroleum, Beijing 102249, China)
深海 海底扇朵叶 沉积构型 构型级次 分布样式 定量规模
deep water submarine-fan lobes depositional architecture architecture hierarchy distribution pattern quantitative scale
As one of the primary sedimentary reservoirs in deep-water sedimentary systems, submarine-fan lobe deposits have important academic value and huge hydrocarbon potential, and thus have always been the hot spot in the study of deep-water sedimentation worldwide. Over nearly 60 years of research, significant progress has been made in respects of submarine-fan lobe concept, sedimentary model and genetic mechanisms. Meanwhile, some controversies also occur, especially on the internal architecture of submarine-fan lobe systems. This paper explains the types and characteristics of architecture elements within the submarine-fan lobe systems, and summarizes and analyzes the submarine-fan lobe architecture hierarchies as well as the spatial distribution patterns and quantitative scale of hierarchical architecture units. On this basis, this paper points out the future study needs to make detailed comparison between the hierarchical concepts of lobe architecture from different researchers. With the architecture hierarchy defined, more efforts are required to understand various development patterns of submarine-fun lobe architecture under control of different geological conditions or dominant factors. A relatively unified, comparable, quantitative architecture knowledge base is expected to be built up eventually, in order to better guide the architecture characterization of submarine lobe reservoirs in the process of deep-water hydrocarbon exploration and development.


[1] SHANMUGAM G.Submarine fans:A critical retrospective(1950-2015)[J].Journal of Palaeogeography,2016,5(2):110-184. [2] NORMARK W R.Growth patterns of deep sea fans[J].AAPG Bulletin,1970,54:2170-2195. [3] MUTTI E.Distinctive thin-bedded turbidite facies and related depositional environments in the Eocene Hecho Group(southcentral Pyrenees,Spain)[J].Sedimentology,1977,24:107-131. [4] BOUMA A H,STELTING C E,COLEMAN J M.Mississippi fan,Gulf of Mexico [G]∥BOUMA A H,NORMARK W R,BARNES N E.Submarine Fans and Related Turbidite Systems.Springer-Verlag,New York,1985:143-150. [5] NELSON C H,MALDONADO A,COUMES F,et al.Ebro fan,Mediterranean [G]∥BOUMA A H,NORMARK W R,BARNES N E.Submarine Fans and Related Turbidite Systems.Springer-Verlag,New York,1985:121-127. [6] ELVERHØI A,NOREM H,ANDERSON E S,DOWDESWELL J A,FOSSEN I,HAFLIDASON H,et al.On the origin and flow behavior of submarine slides on deep-sea fans along the Norwegian-Barents Sea continental margin[J].Geo-Marine Letters,1997,17(2):119-125. [7] SMITH J V.Flow pattern within a Permian submarine slump recorded by oblique folds and deformed fossils,Ulladulla,south-eastern Australia[J].Sedimentology,2000,47(2):357-366. [8] MORRIS E A,HODGSON D M,FLINT S S,et al.Stratigraphic architecture,and depositional context of submarine frontal-lobe complexes[J].Journal of Sedimentary Research,2014,84(9):763-780. [9] GULICK S P S,JAEGER J M,MIX A C,et al.Mid-Pleistocene climate transition drives net mass loss from rapidly uplifting St.Elias Mountains,Alaska[J].Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,2015,112(49):15042-15047. [10] GONG C,STEEL R J,WANG Y,et al.Grain size and transport regime at shelf edge as fundamental controls on delivery of shelf-edge sands to deepwater[J].Earth-Science Reviews,2016,157:32-60. [11] ZHANG J,WU S,HU G,et al.Sea-level control on the submarine fan architecture in a deepwater sequence of the Niger Delta Basin[J].Marine and Petroleum Geology,2018,94:179-197. [12] WALKER R G.Deep-water sandstone facies and ancient submarine fans,models for exploration for stratigraphic traps[J].AAPG Bulletin,1978,62(6):932-966. [13] SHANMUGAM G.High-density turbidity currents:are they sandy debris flows?[J].Journal of Sedimentary Research,1996,66(1):2-10. [14] SHANMUGAM G.The Bouma sequence and the turbidite mind set[J].Earth-Science Reviews,1997,42(4):201-229. [15] SHANMUGAM G.Ten turbidite myths[J].Earth-Science Reviews,2002,58(3):311-341. [16] SHANMUGAM G.New perspectives on deep-water sandstones,origin,recognition,initiation,and reservoir Quality[G]∥Handbook of Petroleum Exploration and Production,Elsevier,Amsterdam,2012,9:524. [17] GARDNER M H,BORER J M.Submarine channel architecture along a slope to basin profile,Brushy Canyon Formation,West Texas [G]∥BOUMA A H,STONE C G.Fine-grained Turbidite Systems:Memoir 72-American Association of Petroleum Geologists and Special Publication 68-SEPM,2000:195-214. [18] MAYALL M,JONES E,CASEY M.Turbidite channel reservoirs—Key elements in facies prediction and effective development[J].Marine and Petroleum Geology,2006,23(8):821-841. [19] 吕明,王颖,陈莹.尼日利亚深水区海底扇沉积模式成因探讨及勘探意义[J].中国海上油气,2008,20(4):275-282. LÜ Ming,WANG Ying,CHEN Ying.A discussion on origins of submarine fan deposition model and its exploration significance in Nigeria deep-water area[J].China Offshore Oil and Gas,2008,20(4):275-282. [20] GERVAIS A,SAVOYE B,MULDER T,et al.Sandy modern turbidite lobes:A new insight from high resolution seismic data[J].Marine and Petroleum Geology,2006,23(4):485-502. [21] SALLER A,WERNER K,SUGIAMAN F,et al.Characteristics of Pleistocene deep-water fan lobes and their application to an upper Miocene reservoir model,offshore East Kalimantan,Indonesia[J].AAPG Bulletin,2008,92(7):919-949. [22] PRÉLAT,A,HODGSON D M,FLINT S S.Evolution,architecture and hierarchy of distributary deep-water deposits:A high-resolution outcrop investigation from the Permian Karoo Basin,South Africa[J].Sedimentology,2009,56(7):2132-2154. [23] PRÉLAT A,COVAULT J A,HODGSON D M,et al.Intrinsic controls on the range of volumes,morphologies,and dimensions of submarine lobes[J].Sedimentary Geology,2010,232(1):66-76. [24] 林煜,吴胜和,王星,等.深水浊积朵叶储层构型模式研究[J].天然气地球科学,2014,25(8):1197-1204. LIN Yu,WU Shenghe,WANG Xing,et al.Research on reservoir architecture models of deep-water turbidite lobes[J].Natural Gas Geoscience,2014,25(8):1197-1204. [25] ZHANG J,WU S,FAN T,et al.Research on the Architecture of Submarine-fan lobes in the Niger Delta Basin,Offshore West Africa[J].Journal of Palaeogeography,2016,5(3):185-204. [26] WYNN R B,CRONIN B T,PEAKALL J.Sinuous deep-water channels:Genesis,geometry and architecture[J].Marine and Petroleum Geology,2007,24(6-9):341-387. [27] KOLLA V,BOURGES P,URRUTY J M,et al.Evolution of deep-water Tertiary sinuous channels offshore Angola(west Africa)and implications for reservoir architecture[J].AAPG Bulletin,2001,85(8):1373-1405. [28] KANE I,HODGSON D.Sedimentological criteria to differentiate submarine channel levee subenvironments:Exhumed examples from the Rosario Fm.(Upper Cretaceous)of Baja California,Mexico,and the Fort Brown Fm.(Permian),Karoo Basin,S.Africa[J].Marine and Petroleum Geology,2011,28(3):807-823. [29] SULLIVAN M,JENSEN G,GOULDING F,et al.Architectural analysis of deep-water outcrops; implications for exploration and development of the Diana Sub-basin,western Gulf of Mexico [C]∥WEIMER P,SLATT R M,COLEMAN J,et al.20th annual Bob F.Perkins research conference.USA(Houston):Society for Sedimentary Geology,Gulf Coast Section,2000:1010-1031. [30] CHAPIN M A,DAVIES P,GIBSON J L.Reservoir architecture of turbidite sheet sandstones in laterally extensive outcrops,Ross formation,Western Ireland [C]∥WEIMER P,BOUMA A H,PETTINGILL H S.Submarine fans and turbidite systems:Gulf Coast Section.Society of Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists,15th Annual Research Conference,1994:53-68. [31] WEIMER P,SLATT R M.Introduction to the petroleum geology of deepwater Settings[J].AAPG Studies in Geology,SEPM Special Publication,2006,57:1-10. [32] STOW D A V,JOHANSSON M.Deep-water massive sands:nature,origin and hydrocarbon implications[J].Marine and Petroleum Geology,2000,17(2):145-174. [33] SHANMUGAM G,SHRIVASTAVA S K,DAS B.Sandy debrites and tidalites of Pliocene reservoir sands in upper-slope canyon environments,offshore Krishna-Godavari Basin(India),implications[J].Journal of Sedimentary Research,2009,79:736-756. [34] LOWE D R.Sediment gravity flows,II.depositional models with special reference to the deposits of high-density turbidity currents[J].Journal of Sedimentary Petrology,1982,52(1):279-297. [35] FLOOD R D,MANLEY P,KOWSMANN R O,et al.Seismic facies and Late Quaternary growth of Amazon submarine fan [G]∥WEIMER P,LINK M H.Seismic Facies and Sedimentary Processes of Submarine Fans and Turbidite Systems.Springer-Verlag,New York,1991:415-433. [36] TWICHELL D C,SCHWAB W C,KENYON N H.Geometry of sandy deposits at the distal edge of the Mississippi Fan,Gulf of Mexico [G]∥PICKERING K T,HISCOTT R N,KENYON N H,et al.Atlas of Deep Water Environments,Architectural Style in Turbidite Systems.Chapman & Hall,London,1995:282-286. [37] ELLIOTT T.Depositional architecture of a sand-rich,channelized turbidite system:The Upper Carboniferous Ross Sandstone Formation,western Ireland [C]∥WEIMER P,SLATT R M,COLEMAN J,et al.Deep-Water Reservoirs of the World:Gulf Coast Section.SEPM 20th Bob F.Perkins Research Conference,2000:342-373. [38] POSAMENTIER H W,KOLLA V.Seismic geomorphology and stratigraphy of depositional elements in deep-water settings[J].Journal of Sedimentary Research,2003,73(3):367-388. [39] MUTTI E,NORMARK W R.An integrated approach to the study of turbidite systems [C]∥WEIMER P,LINK M H.Seismic facies and sedimentary processes of submarine fans and turbidite systems.Springer-Verlag,New York,1991:75-106. [40] HAFLIDASON H,SEJRUP H P,NYGARD A,et al.The Storegga Slide,architecture,geometry and slide development[J].Marine Geology,2004,213(1-4):201-234. [41] SHANMUGAM G.The constructive functions of tropical cyclones and tsunamis on deep-water sand deposition during sea level highstand:implications for petroleum exploration[J].AAPG Bulletin,2008,92(4):443-471. [42] POSTMA G,NEMEC W,KLEINSPEHN K L.Large floating clasts in turbidites,a mechanism for their emplacement[J].Sedimentary Geology,1988,58(1):47-61. [43] MIALL A D.Architectural-element analysis:A new method of facies analysis applied to fluvial deposits[J].Earth-Science Reviews,1985,22(4):261-308. [44] MUTTI E,NORMARK W.Comparing examples of modern and ancient turbidite systems,problems and concepts [G]∥LEGGETT J K,ZUFFA G G.Marine Clastic Sedimentology,Concepts and Case Studies.London.Graham and Trotman,London,1987:1-37. [45] LAMB M A,ANDERSON K S,GRAHAM S A.Stratigraphic architecture of a sand-rich,deep-sea depositional system:The Stevens sandstone,San Joaquin Basin,California[M].Pacific Section AAPG,2003. [46] DEPTUCK M E,PIPER D J W,SAVOYE B,GERVAIS A.Dimensions and architecture of late Pleistocene submarine lobes off the northern margin of East Corsica[J].Sedimentology,2008,55(4):869-898. [47] STRAUB K M,PYLES D R.Quantifying the hierarchical organization of compensation in submarine fans using surface statistics[J].Journal of Sedimentary Research,2012,82(11):889-898. [48] PYLES D R,JENNETTE D C,TOMASSO M,BEAUBOUEF R T,ROSSEN C.Concepts learned from a 3D outcrop of a sinuous slope channel complex:Beacon Channel Complex,Brushy Canyon Formation,West Texas,USA[J].Journal of Sedimentary Research,2010,80(1):67-96. [49] MUTTI E.Turbidite systems and their relations to depositional sequences [G]∥ZUFFA G G.Provenance of Arenites.D.Reidel Publishing Company,Dordrecht,1985:65-93. [50] ZHANG L,MANZOCCHI T,PONTÉN A.Hierarchical parameterisation and modeling of deep-water lobes[C].Petroleum Geostatistics,Biarritz,France,2015. [51] ZHANG L,PAN M,WANG H.Deepwater turbidite lobe deposits:A review of the research frontiers[J].Acta Geologica Sinica(English Edition),2017,91(1):283-300. [52] MUTTI E,RICCI LUCCHI F.Turbidites of the northern Apennines,introduction to facies analysis(English translation by NILSEN T H,1978)[J].International Geology Review,1972,20(2):125-166. [53] HOFSTRA M,HODGSON D,PEAKALL J,et al.Giant scour-fills in ancient channel-lobe transition zones:Formative processes and depositional architecture[J].Sedimentary Geology,2015,329:98-114. [54] MUTTI E,RICCI LUCCI F.Turbidite facies and facies associations,in:examples of turbidite facies and associations from selected formations of the northern Apennines [C]∥IX Int.Congress of Sedimentology,Field Trip A-11,1975:21-36. [55] SHANMUGAM G,MOIOLA R J.Submarine fan models:problems and solutions [G]∥BOUMA A H,NORMARK W R,BARNES N E.Submarine Fans and Related Turbidite Systems.Springer-Verlag,New York,1985:29-34. [56] MIGEON S,MULDER T,SAVOYE B,et al.The Var Turbidite system(Ligurian Sea,northwestern Mediterranean),morphology,sediment supply,construction of turbidite levee,sediment waves and potential reservoirs[J].Geo-Marine Letters,2006,26(6):361-372. [57] READING H G,RICHARDS M.Turbidite systems in deepwater basin margins classified by grain size and feeder system[J].AAPG Bulletin,1994,78(5):792-822. [58] GALES J A,LEAT P T,LARTER R D,et al.Large-scale submarine landslides,channel and gully systems on the outhern Weddell Sea margin,Antarctica[J].Marine Geology,2014,348:73-87. [59] WALTON M A,GULICK S P S,REECE R S,et al.Dynamic response to strike-slip tectonic control on the deposition and evolution of the Baranof fan,Gulf of Alaska[J].Geosphere,2014,10(4):680-691. [60] MASALIMOVA L U,LOWE D R,McHARGUE T,et al.Interplay between an axial channel belt,slope gullies and overbank deposition in the Puchkirchen Formation in the Molasse Basin,Austria[J].Sedimentology,2015,62(6):1717-1748. [61] SURLYK F.Slope and deep shelf gully sandstones,upper Jurassic,east Greenland[J].AAPG Bulletin,1987,71:464-475. [62] FUGELLI E M,OLSEN T R.Delineating confined slope turbidite systems offshore mid-Norway:The Cretaceous deep-marine Lysing Formation[J].AAPG Bulletin,2007,91(11):1577-1601. [63] SWARTZ J M,GULICK S P S,GOFF J A.Gulf of Alaska continental slope morphology:Evidence for recent trough mouth fan formation[J].Geochemistry Geophysics Geosystems,2015,16(1):165-177. [64] HELLER P L,DICKINSON W R.Submarine ramp facies model for delta-fed,sand-rich turbidite sytems[J].AAPG Bulletin,1985,69(6):960-976. [65] GALLOWAY W E,WHITEAKER T L,GANEY-CURRY P.History of Cenozoic North American drainage basin evolution,sediment yield,and accumulation in the Gulf of Mexico basin[J].Geosphere,2011,7(4):938-973. [66] FULTHORPE C S,GALLOWAY W E,SNEDDEN J W,et al.New insights into Cenozoic depositional systems of the Gulf of Mexico basin[J].Gulf Coast Association of Geological Societies Transactions,2014,64:119-129. [67] 于水,程涛,陈莹.尼日尔三角洲盆地深水沉积体系特征[J].地球科学—中国地质大学学报,2012,37(4):763-770. YU Shui,CHENG Tao,CHEN Ying.Depositional characteristics of deepwater systems in the Niger Delta Basin[J].Earth Science—Journal of China University of Geosciences,2012,37(4):763-770. [68] VAIL P R,AUDEMARD F,BOWMAN S A,et al.The stratigraphic signatures of tectonics,eustasy and sedimentology-an overview [G]∥EINSELE G,RICKEN W,SEILACHER A.Cycles and Events in Stratigraphy.Springer-Verlag,Berlin,1991:618-659. [69] BEAUBOUEF R T,FRIEDMANN S J.High resolution seismic/sequence stratigraphic framework for the evolution of Pleistocene intra slope basins,western Gulf of Mexico:depositional models and reservoir analogs [C]∥Deep-water reservoirs of the world:Gulf Coast Section.SEPM 20th Annual Research Conference,2000:40-60. [70] PRATHER B E,PIRMEZ C A,WINKER C D et al.Stratigraphy of linked intraslope basins:Brazos-Trinity system western Gulf of Mexico [G]∥Application of the Principles of Seismic Geomorphology to Continental-Slope and Base-of-Slope Systems:Case Studies from Seafloor and Near-Seafloor Analogues.SEPM Special Publication,2012,99:83-109. [71] 李磊,王英民,徐强,等.被动陆缘深水重力流沉积单元及沉积体系:以尼日尔三角洲和珠江口盆地白云凹陷深水区为例[J].地质论评,2012,58(5):846-853. LI Lei,WANG Yingmin,XU Qiang,et al.Deep-water gravity flow depositional elements and depositional systems in passive margin:Case studies in deep-water areas of Niger Delta and Baiyun Sag,Pearl River Mouth Basin[J].Geological Review,2012,58(5):846-853. [72] CROSS N E,CUNNINGHAM A,COOK R J,et al.Three-dimensional seismic geomorphology of a deep-water slope-channel system,the Sequoia field,offshore west Nile Delta,Egypt[J].AAPG Bulletin,2009,93:1063-1086. [73] MUTTI E,SONNINO M.Compensation cycles; a diagnostic feature of turbidite sandstone lobes [C]∥Anonymous.International Association of Sendimentologists; 2nd European regional meeting.Italy(Bologna):Int.Assoc.Sedimentol.,Oxford,1981,5. [74] GHOSH B,LOWE D R.The architecture of deep-water channel complexes,Cretaceous Venado sandstone member,Sacramento Valley,California [G]∥GRAHAM S A,LOWE D R.Advances in the Sedimentary Geology of the Great Valley Group,Sacramento Valley California.SEPM Pacific Section,1993,7:51-65. [75] BROWNE G H,SLATT R M.Outcrop and behind-outcrop characterization of a late Miocene slope fan system,Mt.Messenger Formation,New Zealand[J].AAPG Bulletin,2002,86(5):841-862. [76] PRÉLAT A,HODGSON D M.The full range of turbidite bed thickness patterns in submarine lobes:controls and implications[J].Journal of the Geological Society,2013,170(1):209-214. [77] SCHLAGER W.Fractal nature of stratigraphic sequences[J].Geology,2004,32(3):185-188. [78] SCHLAGER W.Ordered hierarchy versus scale invariance in sequence stratigraphy[J].International Journal of Earth Sciences,2010,99(1):139-151. [79] STOW D A V,JOHANSSON M.Deep-water massive sands:nature,origin and hydrocarbon implications[J].Marine and Petroleum Geology,2000,17(2):145-174. [80] STRAUB K M,PAOLA C,MOHRIG D,et al.Compensational stacking of channelized sedimentary deposits[J].Journal of Sedimentary Research,2009,79(9):673-688. [81] LIEN T,WALKER R G,MARTINSEN O J.Turbidites in the upper Carboniferous Ross Formation,western Ireland:Reconstruction of a channel and spillover system[J].Sedimentology,2003,50(1):113-148. [82] MACDONALD H A,PEAKALL J,WIGNALL P B,et al.Sedimentation in deep-sea lobe-elements:implications for the origin of thickening-upward sequences[J].Journal of the Geological Society,2011,168(2):319-332. [83] PYLES D R.Multiscale stratigraphic analysis of a structurally confined submarine fan:Carboniferous Ross Sandstone,Ireland[J].AAPG Bulletin,2008,92(5):557-587. [84] BARNES N E,NORMARK W R.Diagnostic parameters for comparing modern submarine fans and ancient turbidite systems [G]∥BOUMA A H,NORMARK W R,BARNES N E.Submarine Fans and Related Turbidite Systems.Springer-Verlag,New York,1985:13-14.


[1]张迎春 杨 莉 顾文欢 杨宝泉 苑志旺 康博韬 郜益华.深海挥发性油藏注气开发气油比变化规律研究及应用[J].中国海上油气,2019,31(05):107.[doi:10.11935/j.issn.1673-1506.2019.05.011]
 ZHANG Yingchun YANG Li GU Wenhuan YANG Baoquan YUAN Zhiwang KANG Botao GAO Yihua.Study on the variation law of gas-oil ratio in gas injection development of deep sea volatile oil reservoirs and its application[J].China Offshore Oil and Gas,2019,31(05):107.[doi:10.11935/j.issn.1673-1506.2019.05.011]


* “十二五”国家科技重大专项“大型油气田及煤层气开发(编号:2011ZX05030-005-002)”部分研究成果。 第一作者简介: 张佳佳,男,博士,现为中国石油大学(北京)博士后研究人员,主要从事海底扇储层表征与建模方面的研究工作。地址:北京市昌平区府学路18号中国石油大学(北京)(邮编:102249)。E-mail:zhangjiajia0103@gmail.com。 通信作者简介: 吴胜和,男,教授、博士生导师,主要从事储层地质学、油藏描述及三维地质建模方面的研究工作。地址:北京市昌平区府学路18号中国石油大学(邮编:102249)。E-mail:reser@cup.edu.cn。
更新日期/Last Update: 1900-01-01